Graduate Courses
Spring 2027
Early Scholastic Philosophy
83227 (40079)
T. Cory
T 9:30a-12:15p
Fullfills Medieval Requirement
This course will study philosophy from the early Scholastic period (roughly, from the late 12th century to 1250), including figures such as Gundissalinus, Philip the Chancellor, William of Auvergne, Robert Grosseteste, Adam of Bocfield, Jean of La Rochelle, Richard Rufus, Alexander Hales, and more. We may also find it opportune to examine the earlier works of Kilwardby, Bonaventure, and Albert the Great. These thinkers are among the "early adopters" of Greek and Arabic philosophy in the Latin West, and provide particularly interesting insights into how the debates emerged that came to characterize medieval philosophy in the second half of the thirteenth century and onward into the fourteenth century. We will focus mainly on metaphysics and anthropology, with specific themes to be determined by group interest. CAVEAT: This is an advanced seminar. Prior coursework in medieval philosophy and at least some basic reading knowledge of Latin is strongly recommended. (English translations of this material are rare or nonexistent. There are tools we can use to generate rough translations for those who would be assisted by having the English side-by-side with the Latin, but during the seminars we will need to refer regularly to the Latin.) Consult with the instructor if you're unsure.
Seminar in Political Philosophy: Constitutionalism, Religious Liberty, and Civic Virtue
83601 (40080)
Audi/Weithman
M 3:30p-6:15p
Fullfills Area 2 Requirement
This course will be a graduate-level exploration of central questions in modern and contemporary political philosophy. Topics to be covered include the limits of government, political legitimacy, freedom of speech, the demands of justice, and the place of religion in the public political argument of a liberal democracy. Readings will be drawn from Locke's Treatise, the Federalist Papers, Mill's On Liberty, and Rawls's A Theory of Justice and Political Liberalism, and other contemporary sources such as Robert Nozick (and possibly the recent writings of the instructors). Students will be expected to participate regularly in seminar discussions, to produce a term paper and to present a preliminary version of that paper pre-circulated to the seminar.
The War on Science
83802 (40081)
Kourany
MW 2-3:15p
Fullfills Area 1 Requirement
What has been called a “war on science” has been occurring at various times and places since at least the 1970s and reported on most usually by science journalists. Recently, however, the war has become especially virulent in the United States and reported on by scientists themselves (see, for example, The War on Science, by Lawrence Krauss, 2025 and Science Under Siege, by Michael Mann and Peter Hotez, 2025). The problem is that there has been no general agreement regarding just who has been waging the war and what a legitimate outcome—a clearly legitimate science--would look like though there has been agreement regarding the extreme seriousness of the present situation. What help might science studies offer? That will be our question, and our resources will include not only various war reports from the past and present but also some of the central pronouncements and debates regarding what science would be and accomplish and has been and accomplished from the very beginnings of modern science onwards. The course will be run as a seminar. Students will lead class discussions, present the results of individual research projects to the group, and have the opportunity to further develop those projects using feedback from the group. The aim in all this will be for each student to develop a fully informed and defensible response to the controversial terrain we shall be exploring.
Philosophy of Logic: Logical Pluralism
83905 (40082)
Beall
W 6:30-9:15p
Fullfills Area 1 Requirement
This seminar will explore central issues in the philosophy of logic, with particular attention to logical pluralism: the idea that there may be more than one correct logic or consequence relation. We will consider different ways of formulating pluralism and monism about logic, along with questions about the nature of logical consequence, the distinction between logical and extra-logical consequence, and the standards by which logics are evaluated. Along the way, we will examine a range of philosophical logics and the philosophical motivations for them. Readings will include both classic and contemporary work, with the precise topics and readings determined in part by the interests of the seminar.
Philosophy Pedagogy Workshop
83105 01 (30024)
Cutter
TBD
Fullfills Pedagogy Requirement
A course required of all graduate students before teaching their own courses for the first time. The goal will be for each prospective teacher to produce viable syllabi and raionales for the courses they will be teaching.
Wagner, Nietzsche, and the Philosophy of Culture
93271 (40833)
Huddleston/O'Connor
W 9:30a-12:15p
Fullfills Modern Requirement
Across Nietzsche’s collected works, there are more references, by far, to his sometime-friend and mentor Richard Wagner than to Plato, Socrates, Kant, or Schopenhauer. In this course, we will look to the music dramas and writings of Wagner, both on their own terms and as a way into key works of Nietzsche’s, which can be seen as inspired by and reacting against Wagner. Works of Wagner’s to be studied include: Tristan und Isolde, Der Ring des Nibelungen, Die Meistersinger von Nürnberg, and Parsifal. Texts of Nietzsche’s to be studied include: The Birth of Tragedy, The Untimely Meditations, Beyond Good and Evil, and The Case of Wagner. Thematically, we will be tracing Wagner’s project of attempted cultural formation and rejuvenation through music drama, and looking to parallel concerns in Nietzsche, along with Nietzschean critiques of Wagner’s nationalism. We will be looking as well to Wagner’s differing treatments of eros across his mature works, and Nietzsche’s sometimes enthusiastic, sometimes critical reactions to Wagner on this, and other, fronts.
Revolution
93302 (41234)
Rush
T 3:30-4:45p
Fullfills Modern Requirement
This is a seminar on conceptions of revolution, both as they figure in social and political theory and as they have been put into practice through social and political action. Focus will be on European ideas of revolution from the eighteenth century onward. More specifically, we shall look at three epochs of the interactivity of theory and practice in revolution: (1) the period from the French Revolution up to the 1848 revolutions, in which classical liberal democratic ideals provide both the content for and against revolution, (2) the period from the socialist and anarchist revolutions of 1848 up to the First World War, in which democratic principles are tested against the rise of capitalism and the nation state, and (3) the period beginning in 1918 and ending with the fall of the Soviet bloc in the 1990s, in which state socialism rises, declines, and falls, only to be resurrected as state-sponsored oligarchy. There are two basic philosophical questions we will consider: (1) what is revolution in the first place? and (2) what conceptual and institutional forms has it taken and might it take? Posing the first question will involve us in considering the differences between revolution and other less far-reaching measures such as reform or resistance. Asking the second question will involve us in debates past and current within revolutionary traditions about the grounds for and conduct of revolution. Given the interactivity of theory and practice that we shall stress, we read both texts that size up as standardly philosophical and texts that may be viewed otherwise—i.e., as historical, political, or anthropological. Our background guide to the relevant historical context is provided by a series of books by the historian Eric Hobsbawm on what he called ‘the long nineteenth’ and the ‘short twentieth’ centuries. Consider this ‘night-table’ reading, i.e., reading to be done ad libitum throughout the term, but unlikely to be the subject of concentrated discussion in seminar. Philosophical readings are drawn from both historical and contemporary material. Caution—these are not dull journal articles that hunt and peck at the margins of issues. They are sustained investigations of our topics: Hobbes, Smith, Rousseau, Proudhon, Marx, Kropotkin, Lenin, Luxemburg, Schumpeter, Marcuse, and Scott.
Formal Philosophy of Mind
93512 (40083)
Elliot
W 12:30-3:15p
Fullfills Area 1 Requirement
It's philosophy of mind, but formal. We'll consider the philosophical issues that arise when we try to construct formalized representations of beliefs and desires, their contents, how they change in response to new evidence and how they figure in the process of decision making. A major theme is the role of rational idealization in the development of these models, and the extent to which we can do without such idealizations. The course presupposes some background in elementary propositional logic, but is otherwise self-contained.
Advanced Topics in Metaphysics
93526 (40084)
McDaniel
R 12:30-3:15p
Fullfills Area 1 Requirement
An investigation of specified topics in metaphysics with an emphasis on recent work in the field. Course content varies by semester and instructor.
Ethics of Climate Change
93608 (40085)
Sterba
MW 2-3:15p
Fullfills Area 2 Requirement
Probabilistic methods are in use in a number of subfields in philosophy---and the influence of these methods, especially over the last couple of decades or so, appears to be growing. In this course, we'll aim to develop an understanding of probabilistic methods in philosophy. The course will consist of three parts. The first part provides a self-contained introduction to the basic formalism of probability spaces. The second part is concerned with different philosophical approaches to probability, with a particular emphasis on subjective and objective types of probability, and the role of principles such as the Principle of Indifference and the Principal Principle. The third part will include an exploration of how probabilistic methods have been used to address epistemological puzzles, as well as puzzles in the sciences---wherein we will work through a number of papers from the recent philosophical literature. (Note that only very minimal background in mathematics and the sciences will be assumed---the course is designed to be largely self-contained.)
Ethics beyond Action
93615 (40086)
Portmore
MW 9:30a-12:15p
Fullfills Area 2 Requirement
Contemporary moral theorizing has often presupposed that we can appropriately assess something as right or wrong only if we have voluntary control over it. As a result, moral theorizing has tended to focus on voluntary actions. In this course, we’ll consider whether this has been a mistake and whether morality extends beyond action. We’ll ask, first, whether such things as racist beliefs, sadistic desires, and malicious intentions can be morally wrong even though we lack voluntary control over them. We’ll also consider whether what we owe others can include a nonvoluntary component. For instance, we may owe someone a sincere apology. But to offer a sincere apology, we must not only voluntarily say “I’m sorry” but also nonvoluntarily feel contrition. What, then, should we say about moral requirements that seem to govern attitudes or feelings beyond our voluntary control? Third, we’ll consider whether morality must extend beyond action in order to address the collective harm problem. As Christopher Kutz observes, “the most important and far-reaching harms…of contemporary life [such as those stemming from climate change] are the products of collective actions, …and individual agents rarely make a difference to [either the severity of these harms or the likelihood of] their occurrence” (2000, 113). Sometimes this is because these harms are overdetermined, so no individual’s action makes any difference to whether, or to what extent, these harms occur. In response, other philosophers argue that morality must not be exclusively act-oriented. Even if an individual’s act is not itself wrong because it makes no difference to the outcome, the individual may nevertheless violate a moral requirement governing something beyond action—for instance, a conditional intention concerning how they would act were they able to make a difference. Finally, the course will culminate in a conference that students will be asked to participate in: https://ethics.nd.edu/news-and-events/conferences/ends/. Nonetheless, participation will, ironically, be voluntary. Tentative syllabus: https://bit.ly/3Xp1WIA
Science as Practical Philosophy
93807 (40087)
Teh
R 9:30a-12:15p
Fullfills Area 1 Requirement
This course will be an exploration of the relationship between a body of work in practical philosophy (viz. the tradition inherited and rearticulated by Elizabeth Anscombe) and its relationship to selected themes and topics in the philosophy of science/physics/mathematics, including: - The action-theoretic aspects of Pierre Duhem's work on the philosophy of science and its relationship to various phenomenological traditions - The philosophy of scientific theories and its relationship to the activity of theorizing and "theorein" - The kind of practical reasoning motivating the introduction of the "new" SI units - The philosophy of replication and reproducibility (especially in relation to the "replicability crisis") - The practical-philosophical issues highlighted by the use of LLMs (+ Lean) in math and physics There will also be room to explore potential synergies between the Anscombean-Wittgensteinian tradition and Continental figures such as Heidegger (especially his writings on science and technology).